“I propose that the U.S. Navy will not provide protection to any ship in international waters that doesn’t meet the requirements established under the Jones Act for domestic shipping. Does this sound reasonable to you?”
No, because we would in effect be forcing our domestic law (the Jones Act applies to shipping between US ports, not international shipping) on the rest of the world.
The current scenario is beyond retarded. If you are a maritime shipping company you have every financial and regulatory incentive to domicile your company and flag your vessels in any country but the U.S. — and you can still count on the U.S. taxpayers to pay for the military protection of your ships. It’s astonishing that any American with half a brain would think this makes sense.