Posted on 06/16/2023 3:31:37 PM PDT by nickcarraway
A standout album in a remarkable career, ‘Is That All There Is?’ dared to be different, revealing a new versatility to Peggy Lee’s singing.
Peggy Lee was 49 years old when Capitol Records released Is That All There Is? in 1969. It was her 42nd album, and it had been over 10 years since the singer born Norma Deloris Egstrom, in 1920, had last graced the US Top 40 with her presence; her sultry take on Little Willie John’s “Fever” scaled the upper echelons of the American hit parade in 1958.
But Lee, a country girl with Scandinavian ancestry who hailed from the plains of North Dakota, had more in the tank. The haunting and idiosyncratic “Is That All There Is?” (inspired by a short story called Disillusionment from German writer Thomas Mann) captured the public imagination when it was released as a single in the States and started climbing the pop charts, where it peaked at No.11. Such was the song’s impact that it won Lee a Grammy Award in the category of Best Contemporary Female Vocal Performance in 1970. Its success was a surprise to Capitol, who thought the song was too odd and esoteric to be a hit.
The song opens Lee’s album of the same name and, even today, remains a profoundly potent piece of music. It has the ability to simultaneously provoke conflicting emotions, eliciting both laughter and pathos. Combining a spoken narrative with a plaintive refrain sung over a jaunty rhythm, it evokes the Berlin cabaret scene of the 1920s and the spirit of German composer Kurt Weill. The song was penned and produced by noted hitmakers Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, and it’s unlike anything else they wrote: a philosophical rumination that questions the meaning of things.
Arranged and conducted by a young Randy Newman, “Is That All There Is?” is beautifully delivered by Lee in plangent tones, mixing a droll, ironic humor with a poignant reflection on the absurdity and, indeed, disappointments of life. Despite the song’s somber mood and theme of disillusionment, the chorus is gloriously carefree: “Let’s keep dancing/Let’s break out the booze and have a ball,” Lee sings, and she sounds like she means it. (Understandably, the song – which was originally written for, and turned down by, Marlene Dietrich – has inspired many covers over the years, including notable versions by Tony Bennett and PJ Harvey with John Parish.)
Though it was the undoubted cornerstone of Is That All There Is?, there was much more to enjoy besides the title song. Another Leiber and Stoller composition, “Whistle For Happiness,” is stylistically similar to “Is That All There Is?” while their “I’m A Woman” is a swaggering, sassy blues that was first cut by Lee on her 1963 album of the same name and was a minor US chart hit at the time.
Elsewhere, Lee deconstructs the Al Jolson-associated “Me And My Shadow” and imbues it with a languorous sensuality. Another highlight is her take on Randy Newman’s “Love Story (You And Me),” the opening cut on the singer-songwriter’s 1968 debut album for Reprise, which is arranged and conducted by the composer himself. Newman’s “Johnny (Linda)” is also included and has an arrangement that recalls the vaudevillian quirkiness of the album’s title track.
Lee also embraced the rock music zeitgeist by tackling The Beatles’ George Harrison-penned “Something” and Neil Diamond’s gospel-flavored “Brother Love’s Travelling Salvation Show,” though she does them in her own inimitable way. And while the original album ran to ten tracks in the US, UK fans who had been denied the pleasure of her Lee’s 1967 Somethin’ Groovy album were treated to some of its delights on a 2003 reissue that included four bonus tracks from the earlier record, among them the Nancy and Frank Sinatra duet “Somethin’ Stupid,” reconfigured into a breezy bossa nova.
Is That All There Is? dared to be different and showed that, though Peggy Lee was often typecast as a stereotypical jazz chanteuse, she was a much more versatile performer than had hitherto been revealed. Though its title song is an ode to coping with disappointment, that particular emotion is the last thing that you feel when listening to this classic album, which is a life-affirming delight from beginning to end.
I remember there was a blooper where some announcer called her “Leggy Pee”.
I believe I bought the single in 1967. Solid tune, definitely imbued with languorous sensuality.
Yup,great,great song.
“Is That All There Is?”
I remember saying those same words when I heard the first Beatles song (I want to hold your hand). Her song came out years later.
I was one of the few students in High School who was not engrossed by The Beatles.
The emperor, clothes, etc.
I remember when this song, “Is That All There is?” came out. Everyone I knew hated it. Even my parents who were both Peggy Lee fans hated it. Mom would turn the radio off when it came on.
It’s hard to hear.
The film “They Shoot Horses, Don’t They” came out about the same time. The entertainment industry was getting into a dark mood.
Folks on the Hill. Peggy Lee
“Yup,great,great song.”
It is, it really is.
Then let’s keep dancing
Let’s break out the booze and have a ball!
Most depressing song I ever heard.
I liked and understood this song the first time I heard it, summer of 1969. I was in Junior High.
Some people didn’t want to hear it for a long while.
Maybe because for the last few years, some of the Top 10 songs had melancholy themes: 1967; Ode To Billie Joe by Bobby Gentry
1968; Honey by Bobby Goldsborough.
*Is That All There Is was inspired by a short story by
German Novelist Thomas Mann “Disillusionment”.
I have read one, maybe two of Mann’s books.
Difficult reading. Each sentence jam packed with information, both said and left unsaid.
One of the pleasures of getting to 68 (in a few days) is that I can sit here (some mornings, when I've slept very well) and let my mind range out across my life's experience. And a lot of things do make sense, that long ago frustrated, or hurt, or otherwise vexed me.
I see them. I understand them.
Why my parents did (or didn't do) certain things.
Why certain females broke my heart.
Why certain bosses did things I thought were dumb.
Not everything, certainly, but a lot of things.
I feel lucky to be able to say that.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.