Which team?
With Derick Carr signing for $3.5 million, the Saints are out but the Jets and Colts and still looking for their QB.
The Jets could go with Rogers, but he is expensive and old.
The Colts only other option would be to trade up in the draft, but the Bears will want a high price for the number one pick.
It also looks like Carolina and Tampa are in the market.
So yes, it is unlikely that the Giants are being charitable and paying far above market rates.