David Gilmour was the musical soul of Pink Floyd.
Not really. PF was pretty much Waters, especially from Dark Side on, until he left. He pretty much wrote everything and came up with the concepts, the other three were basically studio musicians.
They had no soul. They were ugly. Unless it was their crazy founder.
++++++++++
Waters is a prick. Gilmour is not. Waters wrote great lyrics. Gilmour was the better talent playing music. Waters music on its own is not very appealing and some is quite boring. Neither was really outstanding without the other. If on an island I would have to go with Gilmours guitar before Rogers voice / lyrics. My $0.02
++++++++++
Waters is a prick. Gilmour is not. Waters wrote great lyrics. Gilmour was the better talent playing music. Waters music on its own is not very appealing and some is quite boring. Neither was really outstanding without the other. If on an island I would have to go with Gilmours guitar before Rogers voice / lyrics. My $0.02