++++++++++
Waters is a prick. Gilmour is not. Waters wrote great lyrics. Gilmour was the better talent playing music. Waters music on its own is not very appealing and some is quite boring. Neither was really outstanding without the other. If on an island I would have to go with Gilmours guitar before Rogers voice / lyrics. My $0.02
The other thing is that Waters treated Rick Wright like crap. And some of my favorite early PF songs are Wright’s songs like “Paintbox”.