No, he should not be in. He was a solid player but should not have been voted in.
Once Harold Baines and Tim Raines were inducted into the Hall of Fame, the HOF was basically admitting that it’s standards are pretty low anyway.
Pretty good examination of his candidacy here:
https://blogs.fangraphs.com/jaws-and-the-2023-hall-of-fame-ballot-scott-rolen/
I would feel a lot better about his candidacy if he had put together some more solid counting stats. He missed a lot of time with injuries and he fell off rapidly late in his career. A lot of his value was from defense and that’s hard to evaluate with numbers. But I did seem him play a lot (Phillies fan) and he was a great third baseman.
Certainly could argue either way with him.