I will say this about the three ST movies with Pine. The actors chosen to portray versions of the original characters seem more believable and well chosen (with the exception of Uhura). Karl Urban as McCoy and Zachary Quinto as Spock are excellent, IMO. As far as it goes, Pine isn’t a bad choice either.
I really wasn’t that crazy about them, I’ll spare the details as to why, which you can probably guess. I thought they should’ve left well enough alone and done a new cast of characters 150-200 years after the original series.
If you’re going to do the original people, use the deep-fake method and employee voice actors who can accurately impersonate them (or just do a cartoon, a la the Animated Series from the ‘70s).