What is your criticism of the study?
Name calling or shaming are not arguments.
Linking to non-comparable graphs is not an argument.
One of the simplest statistics that is less subject to manipulations is overall mortality rates by age group. They can’t be distorted by shifting or counting causes of deaths differently between categories.
One is.. the links in this study that would prove the data DO NOT WORK.
I have seen the relationship between vaccination BY GERMAN STATE and Covid infection and death rates. The lowest vaccinated state (Saxony) has the HIGHEST Covid death rate.
I'm still looking for the actual "excess death" data in Germany. I know, from previous looking, that such data take a little time to be complete. I don't trust reports that include links that don't work.