Thanks nickcarraway.
Posted on 01/26/2021 3:35:45 PM PST by nickcarraway
The current holders of a valuable violin are under growing pressure to pay compensation to the heirs of its Jewish former owner, whose family music shop was seized by the Nazis.
The rare instrument, built in 1706 by the celebrated Italian luthier Giuseppe Guarneri, is worth approximately 150,000 euros, or around £133,200. But if it was repaired to its full glory, experts say it would be with at least $1 million.
It came into Felix Hildesheimer’s possession in 1938. The music shop owner took over his father’s business in 1898 and bought the rare instrument from a Stuttgart-based music dealer decades later.
Mr Hildesheimer’s shop was subjected to boycotts and later seized by the Nazis. After several unsuccessful attempts to flee the country, he committed suicide in 1939.
His wife Helene was deported to southern France a year later but survived and fled to the US in 1941. She is survived by her grandchildren Sidney Strauss and David Sand.
The violin resurfaced in 1974 when it was sold to violinist Sophie Hagemann by a luthier in Cologne. After her death in 2010, the violin went to her sole heir, the Franz Hofmann und Sophie Hagemann Stiftung, a foundation which seeks to promote young musical talent.
The foundation has said it wishes to have the violin restored and lent to students at the Nuremberg University of Music.
A mediation panel found in 2016 it was “very likely” the violin was sold under duress or seized by the Nazis.
The Limbach Commission, which handles disputes over Nazi looted art, said the foundation could keep the violin but that it should pay 100,000 euros in compensation to Mr Hildesheimer’s heirs, around £88,850.
But the foundation has not yet made a single payment, the panel revealed last week, accusing the organisation of ignoring “established standard of knowledge about living conditions” in Nazi Germany.
“For four years now, the community of heirs, whose German ancestors were subjected to severe persecution under National Socialism, has been given the impression that a political lack of will and bureaucratic hurdles stood in the way of reparation for historical injustice in Germany.
“The advisory commission considers it particularly inappropriate that the Hagemann Foundation continues to claim that its handling of the matter makes the violin an ‘instrument of reconciliation’.”
But the foundation said in a statement that “bureaucratic hurdles” had hampered its efforts to raise the sum.
It also cast doubt on the validity of the panel’s recommendation, arguing that new research suggested Mr Hildesheimer had not yet forcibly sold his shop when he purchased the violin.
“It can therefore be assumed that the violin was sold as a retail product in the music shop, because it does not appear in the list of expropriated items made by the family after the war.”
It also said it had “tried to proactively clarify the provenance of the violin and always proceeded transparently and with full awareness of the responsibility involved.”
And like their 1930’s national socialist german worker’s party brethren, modern leftists are openly talking about seizing property of people they find “problematic”.
Someone who would have appreciated a violin of such high standards would be the late violinist Yehudi Menuhin, (1916 to 1999) an American born violin virtuoso. He performed for Allied soldiers during WW2, and surving inmates of a number of concentration camps in July 1945, after their liberation in April of the same year. I don’t know a lot about him.
I just happened to hear some of his music and was more or less swept away with his skills and interpretations of Bach and Bartok pieces.
George Soros’s m.o..
Yes.
I recall how excited and animated he was when talking about the glorious heady days of his youth collaborating with actual nazis.
They still try to scrub that interview or explain it away.
That was 80 years ago.
Does ‘money grubbing’ have a statute of limitations?
How long would you be unhappy about something stolen from you or your family?
Looks like he’s in position to do it again.
You mean like a republic?
Or a damned old violin?
Yeah, it does.
A friend of mine has a violin that was made in the 1730’s.
I’m no music expert but the sound is amazing.
The ‘bankers’ stole 1/2 million dollars from my grandfather in 1929 while he was on a ship in the pacific.
My father never mentioned it as a victim, not once.
I suppose some people need to be victims, forever.
The article is about a violin that is worth money.
The person the violin was stolen from died 82 years ago.
There is no ‘attachment’ to this instrument on the part of the family, it’s just the money.
And everyone knows it.
Thanks nickcarraway.
Anastasiya Petryshak - J.S. Bach - Ciaccona, Partita n.2 in Re minore
159,433 views
Oct 18, 2013
MdV - Museo del Violino
Anastasiya suona il violino Guarneri del Gesù 1734, Stauffer
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e99D0gnqG-c
https://artsandculture.google.com/asset/in-concert/LAEHqNS8VXrQYQ?hl=en&childassetid=uAHNs1Q5eQ46hg
“I played three notes and I thought I was going to die” - how Itzhak Perlman found his Stradivarius
10,999 views
Dec 13, 2018
92nd Street Y
Itzhak Perlman tells us how he acquired his famous Stradivarius.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcUprL2ET-4
Couple of videos you might find interesting.
First— how Itzhak Perlman came to own Yehudi Menuhin’s Stradivarius:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcUprL2ET-4
And a great video of the French( Famous violinist from the 30’s HotClubJazz Quartet with Django Reinhardt the greatest of all gypsy jazz guitarists) here with the very un-stuck up Yehudi playing Jealousy:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dzIEaNRoj3k
Yehudi is an all time favourite, along with Itzhak Perlman and the great Jascha Heifetz.
Violinmaker Hans Benning Remembers Violinist Jascha Heifetz
62,223 views
Dec 17, 2018
Benning Violins
Los Angeles luthier and violinmaker, Hans Benning, remembers his 15-year relationship with “Violinist of the Century” Jascha Heifetz.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IlU9BTYnxdM
During the last ten years of his life, Heifetz visited Hans Benning at Benning Violins for maintenance on his 1740 Guarneri violin.
The Theft, Recovery, and Legend of Joshua Bell’s Red Stradivarius Violin | Robb Report
224,197 views
Nov 2, 2018
Robb Report
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q9aVKP4jG80
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
