Hesler took a total of four portraits at this sitting. Lincoln's law partner William Herndon wrote of this picture: There is the peculiar curve of the lower lip, the lone mole on the right cheek, and a pose of the head so essentially Lincolnian; no other artist has ever caught it."
Here is a June 2, 1860 newspaper page from the Evansville Daily Journal of Evansville, Indiana. Note Lincoln’s responses to Douglas’s questions on the left side of the paper.