[nickcarraway]

Do you have a citation?

[Western Patriot]

The original Lynch version was a poor adaptation. The mini series was excellent and very true to the book. The author who created this review doesn’t have an clue and probably never read the books. I met Frank Herbert back in the 70’s in Port Townsend. It was an honor and privilege. I will wait and see what the new dune is like but not going to judge it until I see it.

[Nateman]

Do you have a citation?

No. I base my opinion on having read the book

[Nateman]

Try this. I was not aware of this article but it came up in a search and it makes my case.