Pretty certain you are describing "The Nut Shop" in downtown Nashville's Arcade, a super-cool cut-through of shops dead center of the city. Also home of Manny's Pizza, who's nephew set up down the road with his recipes and got in Top Ten Pizza Places in America. Go to Manny's - he charges less for the same supreme quality. His pepperoni calzones take no prisoners.
Speaking of nostalgia you can’t beat Free Republic’s tendency to double post after all these years. But we still love you.