Posted on 09/07/2018 12:41:28 PM PDT by Simon Green
The Tiger and the Panther were not inferior in design or construction. But very complicated to manufacture and difficult to maintain in the field. The Sherman and the Soviet T-34s manufactured in the hundreds of thousands were the deciders of victory in the ETO
I know for a fact Patton was not happy with the tanks. Especially gasoline powered ones.
I guess it is a matter of opinion as to which was the best tank of WWII.
I have read that many, maybe most consider one of the later models of the Panther was the best all around tank of the war.
No, and you can add the FW190 and the ME262 as superior weapons as well, albeit air war. Still, this letter was a nice stroking of the 'production front' for a job very well done! As such, this letter may have been too much of fulsome praise, but being written in January of 1945, AFTER the Battle of the Bulge was effectively won, it is, to me, more than just a jingoistic paean for all American weapons. For the time and place it was written, it was the abundance of weapons, M1 and all, that Patton is giving good praise not as a weapon by weapon comparison.
It was the Reising gun they didn’t like much. Many were OK with the 1903, but in the circumstances the M1 was a better choice.
At 85, that picture is one the few things that can still give me a woody...
The best tank in the world doesn’t make any difference if the odds are 10 to one. Yes the Americans or Soviets may lose 5 or 6 tanks against a single Panther. But the inevitable conclusion is a destroyed Panther. The Americans and the Reds could manufacture 10 adequate tanks for every one superior tank the Germans could manufacture. We won, they lost.
M1 Garand,,,
Good to know!
Oh, they liked the 1903 Springfield, but they wanted the M1 Garand.
Any chance of posting the
Winning Bid???
I have a 1943 mosin. Looks like it was put together by moe, Larry and curly. But it shoots straight.
CC
Ping
Gar-end, not Ga-Rand.
One of the first things my Dad taught me about the M1. I still shoot the H&R NM M1 he built for me in the mid 70’s, it wear a new Krieger barrel and a full pressure bedded stock/unitized front end etc.
I had not thought about it before but 50+ years ago I knew a beautiful girl named Garand. She pronounced it Gare-und.
And M-1’s could give good hickeys, also known as M-1 thumbs.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.