>>They were reportedly at odds over whether Halle Berry would be a good fit for the role.<<
The one who said “Halle Berry” = bad is correct. She is too petite and exquisite to play Aretha.
The First Lady of Soul was beautiful but big boned. I already am on record as voting for pre-”DreamGirls” Jennifer Hudson
Or Angela Bassett. She was always good but she’s awesome in the TV show 911.