Posted on 11/23/2017 11:57:56 AM PST by EveningStar
aren’t the originals way AFTER this crew? Would they appear as children?
IIRC, Discovery takes place 10 years before TOS.
so the crew is how old? Pre academy?
As I noted, it’s not just that it’s a format for PC talking points - it also just stinks as a show.
Even the worst of the real ST outings, “Enterprise”, had an ensemble cast whom interacted well - that’s 99% of the secret of the real-mccoy ST franchise. With this latest dump of excrement you got one emo girl trying to work out her personal issues in the midst of an overwhelming boatload of CGI.
Also, you can take any one episode (or the rare two-parter) of the real ST outings and it stands on it’s own. In this emo-girl version it’s an ongoing Perils Of Pauline soap opera-serial.
Dunno about “Orville” as I haven’t watched it, but I understand it’s a comedy space parody. That it is being compared as an alternative to Discovery is something I would consider telling of to how far ST has fallen - i.e. the apple is the same as the orange. It’s embarrassing.
(If I want a comedy space parody, I’d go with Mel Brook’s “Spaceballs”.)
At any rate, people who like to watch Discovery should do it while they still can, before it’s taken off the intertubes.
I do not like Orville. It could be described as The Simpsons in Space only with live actors and no Simpsons.
“I do not like Orville. It could be described as The Simpsons in Space only with live actors and no Simpsons.”
—
The Simpsons can get pretty annoying in it’s forays into leftism, too. I think it’s pretty much run it course anyway, as far as creativity goes, haven’t watched it for years. Was pretty good in it’s early years.
Here’s a couple thoughtful & friendly looks at “Discovery” and where it is lacking, as opposed to my concise “Yeecchhh!”.
https://filmschoolrejects.com/star-trek-discovery-serious
https://comicsverse.com/star-trek-discovery-midseason-review
Kirk was 34 in TOS, so he would be 24 in Discovery time.
Kirk, Spock, McCoy, Scotty - post academy. McCoy was an MD and didn’t attend academy.
Chapel was either in the academy or post academy.
Sulu and Uhura were probably in the academy.
Checkov and Rand were probably pre-academy (despite Grace Lee Whitney’s age)
thanx I’m lazy poster
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.