‘That still leaves the fact that no one saw Stanley Ann in Hawaii, other than Neil Abercrombie who said he saw the Kenyan with ‘Ann’ and the baby on social occasions, and Kiri Tith who said he knew Ann or Anne but had no idea she had married or had a child to the Kenyan.’
We’ve discussed Kiri Tith. Apparently in vain. This idea of yours that a seasoned biography sits down with an interviewee and says, ‘So, did you know an Ann or Anne, ~45 years ago,’ couldn’t be farther from the truth. Maraniss was asking about ‘Stanley Ann Dunham.’ To insist that he wouldn’t have made that clear is simply detached from reality.
Cindy Pratt not only saw Stanley Ann Dunham in HI; she lived in the same house with her. No, it wasn’t a case of mistaken identify. Stanley Ann took her baby and showed him to Cindy after she returned to HI. Cindy would not have mistaken Stanley Ann Dunham for the mythical Ann; SAD wasn’t gone long enough for Cindy to forget completely what she looked like.
“...Cindy Pratt not only saw Stanley Ann Dunham in HI; she lived in the same house with her. No, it wasn’t a case of mistaken identify. Stanley Ann took her baby and showed him to Cindy after she returned to HI.”
repeating comment 66:
I looked for Cindy’s comments to Maraniss and all I could find was this:
http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2012/06/maraniss_bio_deepens_obama_birth_mystery.html
“Maraniss hints at where home was not — namely, the residence her parents shared with the Pratt family at 6085 Kalanianole Highway, the address listed on the birth certificate. As Maraniss relates, the Pratt daughter, then an adolescent, “has no memory of the Dunhams’ daughter bringing an infant home.” He adds, “[Ann] and Obama and the infant never lived [at 6085 Kalanianole].”
As I do not have access to the book, perhaps you could quote from it, exactly what she said to Maraniss. Thanks.
============end quote
May I suggest we drop it now? I really don’t want to repeat everything I’ve been trying to show since heaven knows how long ago...and you don’t want to see it, right? It’s futile, we are both just defending our own impressions, and there’s no progress possible. Like I said earlier, you were two thirds of the way there, and two out of three isn’t all that bad.
https://www.freerepublic.com/focus/chat/3580997/posts?page=32#32
1, No eyewitness places Obama’s mother in HI at any point during her pregnancy.
2, Stanley Ann was not living at the Kalanianaole Highway address, the ‘home,’ listed on both the BC and the birth announcements, nor (per a resident of the house) did she bring a baby home from the hospital to that address.
3, The first actual sighting of Obama’s mother after her 9 mo disappearance was in Seattle. She had a newborn with her at the time.