I had not seen those tops. Originally, I was going to get her something that stood up pretty high above the lid, but I don’t think it would have fit on her pantry shelf. The pickle pipes are no problem.
The pickle pipes folks sent me a nice e-book with my order & I’d love to do some fermented foods - another project to take up in the future. :-)
Actually, your tops look easier to use and clean. I’ll show them to husband.