So I am in need of a conservative auto/home insurance company
I have used Nationwide and their affiliate Allied been very happy, supports the NASCAR crowd
Good luck on finding any product or service that operates within your social constraints.
The best you can do is tolerate whatever liberal excesses they may have.
Hell, if I were to boycott every company that I have legitimate concerns over their social policies, I’d have to go Gault and live off the grid.
Is USAA your best value? Yes? Then stick with them.
Or you could do George Soros a favor and go with Progressive.
(mega barf)
Armed Forces Insurance:
http://www.afi.org/Is-AFI-for-you/Overview
They operate out of the Fort Leavenworth, Kansas area.
I don’t know if they have conservative values, but I think Clark Howard recommends Amica.
American Financial Insurance is the only major personal lines auto insurance company more conservative/more Republican than USAA ... if you consider where they put their money.
Agents are far more conservative than big companies, on average. That is true of both independent agents and agents captive of a single company.
Consider also the agent you go with.
GEICO and Progressive are absolutely the worst.
Use 2ndvote.com to find conservative businesses to patronize or work for.