[bella1]

So lets see if I follow you logic correctly. Lets say I am replacing my front door with a new door that I really like that happens to be the last one the store has in stock. I make the purchase, bring the door home and have it installed, but wait! One of the store employees decides that they want that very door, and given that it is the last one in stock, the owner of said store demands that I remove it from my house and give it to his employee. When I of course say NO, the police are called, the door is ripped from its hinges doing damage to my home in the process and I am the one going to jail? Just trying to follow your logic.

[madball]

Very nicely put. A great analogy.

[grania]

Nice analogy. What if that's the same day that you have purchased a ticket to go to a concert. You're seated, waiting for the concert to begin. Then someone walks up to you and says "You have to leave. We've decided that someone else needs your seat".

If UAL gets anything but the worst possible condemnation and punishment for their horrendous policy, both your example and mine would be logically okay.

[MortMan]

You are missing the fact that the LAW requires that the crew be accommodated - not simply “desire”.

[publius911]

Dumb!
Dumb!
Dumb!

"Juvenile" is an understatement.

A door, huh?