[John Valentine]

Sharia Law could be separated from Islam so that Islam could be compatible with the western world.

Only in your dreams, pal.

First off there is no human being authorized to change laws that come from God himself.

Second, even if the changes you want did come from God, there is no way to prove it. especially to a Muslim whose entire belief system rotates on the pivot that Mohammad was and remains God's final prophet. Good luck getting past that one.

Third, any Muslim promulgating such a thing would be killed for heresy and apostasy likely within the first thirty days. It's happened before. Apostasy and heresy are frowned upon in the Muslim world.

[abigkahuna]

Not in my dreams John, only in my feeble brain. I totally understand what you are saying and do not disagree. The question remains, Constitutionally, how does the government deal with such a doctrine? Label it as un-American?

[Elsie]

First off there is no human being authorized to change laws that come from God himself.

There are PLENTY of men that CLAIM stuff comes from 'GOD'.