Posted on 10/10/2015 9:25:02 PM PDT by Swordmaker
A federal magistrate in Brooklyn is temporarily refusing to order Apple to disable security on a device seized by the government, citing Congress' failure to act on the hot-button issue of encryption despite urging from law enforcement officials.
"Congress has done nothing that would remotely suggest an intent to force Apple, in the circumstances of this case, to provide the assistance the government now requests," U.S. Magistrate James Orenstein said in his ruling, posted on the court's website Thursday afternoon. "Several of its members have introduced legislation to prohibit exactly what the government now asks the court to compel."
. . .
He provided few details on the government's Thursday application asking him to order Apple to help, saying only that the government had a warrant to seize the device but couldn't unlock it, and leaving out details that might compromise the investigation.
(Without) clear legislation, Orenstein said, he had to consider how burdensome an order would be on Apple, and noted that forcing (...Apple...) could affect carefully considered commercial decisions on the balance between public safety and privacy.
Orenstein said the government claimed that in "other cases" Apple was ordered to assist law enforcement and had complied, but he said he found only one published court opinion on the issue, in which an unnamed manufacturer was ordered last year to assist the government.
. . .
Andrew Crocker, a lawyer with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, said he believed that Orenstein was the first judge to question the government's legal authority under the so-called "All Writs Act" to compel Apple to unlock a phone.
But he also said the issue may be moot if the device in question is of recent vintage, because Apple itself is unable to de-encrypt its new operating systems and will probably tell the court so.
(Excerpt) Read more at newsday.com ...
Ping to dayglored; thundersleeps; and Shadow Ace for their ping lists.
If you want on or off the Mac Ping List, Freepmail me.
To me this is The Big Show, the prelude to proceeding or disaster
We as a Nation have been given a last chance to return to the commitment made by Washingon of this Country to God
We now must Choose each our own way and so it will proceed until the bill is called in
God Bless
If Apple has the ability to comply with such an order, that is a bug.
They don’t have that ability with the current OS. I’m more inclined to trust “can’t” than “won’t”.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.