[ClearCase_guy]

I merely mean that I don't see this as completely black or white -- you either think Josh is a bad person OR you enthusiastically support child rape. I think a slightly more nuanced view of the situation should be possible.

I will say that Josh was wrong.
I will say that people who want to protect children are right.

So: Right and Wrong DO enter into this.

But can we can ANYTHING at all with a bit of nuance? Or are we mandated to simply say that Josh is a bad, vile, hateful person?

Because that seems a tad simplistic to me.

[9YearLurker]

That’s okay—but you haven’t really explained the “nuance” you see that makes this other than an issue of right or wrong.