Posted on 11/02/2014 1:43:05 PM PST by Morgana
We keep hearing about the right to die. There is no right to dieno escape, of course,but no right.
Yet, I hasten to add. No right to die, yet.
What do I mean? The killing decision in euthanasia and assisted suicide isnt really the suicidal persons choice: It is the killers or helpers. In other words, life will end only if the joint venturer in the killing believes the suicidal persons life is not worth living.
davidmixnerThis ultimate truth about euthanasiaeven in wild death cultures like Belgium and the Netherlandscame to mind as I read about gay activist David Mixners confession that he mercy-killed 8 friends with AIDS during the height of the epidemic. From the Daily Beast story:
Into this network, says Mixner, came medical professionalsnurses and doctors, heavily into the epidemicwho saw what AIDS did to their patients and the lack of effective medicine to lessen their suffering, and who wanted to provide death with dignity.
I would only do it when I was 100 percent sure that there was no hope, Mixner tells me. When I felt there was no hope, that all had been done for them, then I would do it. Some of the patients got angry. Theyd say, We want to die now. But I could only help to do it when it felt right to me.
In other words, it was Mixners choice. And the killing was not a medical act, but people know that.
I moved to San Francisco at the height of the AIDS catastrophe. The underground euthanasia network Mixner described was well known.
This was the time I began my anti-assisted suicide activism, As my public profile rose, I would be invited to debate in SF about The Citys underground euthanasia network.
In debating the underground killing network it became clear how subjective the kill decision was for assisters. One doctor told me in a debate that he wouldnt do it unless the patient got below 90 pounds. That was his personal line and he stuck to it!
I challenged him:But your colleagues have different lines, dont they? He admitted they did. Some didnt wait very far along in the death process at all.
Also, I sensed that the assisted suicide virus was as contagious as HIV. Dying in that way came to be seen as an act of defiance against an oppressive culture. The idea was, You cant tell us who to love or how to die,astonishing to me at the time that gay rights would be conjoined with the killing of (mostly) gay men.
So, whether a despairing and sick AIDS patient was killed depended on whether the killer thought the ill gay mans life was still worth living!
Perhaps Mixner feels guilty in making his confession. Why? When the new drugs suddenly burst on the scene, AIDS patients literally bounced back from deaths door to vitality. In other words, some of those killed by the euthanasia network might not have died at all but for being the subject of homicide!
Click here to sign up for daily pro-life news alerts from LifeNews.com
The same doctors choice phenomenon occurs in Oregon, Belgium, Netherlands, etc. This leads to what I call doctor shopping, that is, the suicidal person looking for a medic with a prescription pad willing to kill or help kill them under their individual circumstances. Heck, even Kevorkian said no once in a while.
But Wesley, you always warn that assisted suicide will end up in death on demand! Indeed, it will.
The idea is to turn euthanasia into abortion. In Victoria, Australia, every doctor must be complicit in abortion-on-demand, either by doing the fetus killing or referring to a doctor know to be willing.
The KNMG (Dutch Medical Association) issued an ethical opinionnot yet lawopining that Dutch doctors opposed to a legally qualified patient being euthanized must refer to a death doctor willing to do the snuffing.
In Quebec, that is already the lawand the homicide is paid for by the state.
But for now, the right to die is mostly the right to lethally prescribe or administer if asked. Think about the power in thatthe right to determine whether another person lives or dies.
LifeNews.com Note: Wesley J. Smith, J.D., is a special consultant to the Center for Bioethics and Culture and a bioethics attorney who blogs at Human Exeptionalism.
Wow.
Love Hogans Heroes , yes I pretty much knew you were not a fan of The Daily Beast
I only know that the guy who runs it, is a phony loser CNN tried to pass off as a Conservative for a number of yuears.
I actually saw him the other night (was only surfing the dial) on Bill M on HBO
Bill M (loser) called him a Conservative and he had a hard time hiding his laughter, moderate Mary Madeline (sp) Carvilles wife, laughed at the thought also that he was Conservative...funny wondering how Conservative she could be
No I dont watch the show, I check it out on occasion just to see what they are saying...more than you wanted to know
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.