The logic is situational.
I remember buying new tires during the Carter years (that I wouldn't have normally bought) because inflation was 25% and I reckoned that I was better off with the tires than the money.
You bet the logic is situational. To expand the analogy further, if you’re completely inept at changing oil or really hate it, its probably smarter to earn the money, pay the taxes, and pay someone to change it for you.
Or you might instead trade a friend 3 jars of honey and have no cash change hands. And you’ve added value. Not all value involves the use of money.