I know what you mean. Vince Lombardi, Bear Bryant, John Madden, Bobby Bowden were all such lousy NFL players & physical specimens. How could they judge a quarterback's potential? /s
Yes, but all of those gentlemen had great success as coaches, so now we respect their opinions.
Trent Dilfer has had nothing but his mediocre NFL career. I’m just asking why his word convinces anyone of anything? Its like saying someone is going to win an election because Susan Estrich thinks they have great campaign skills, and she should know because she helped Mike Dukakis win the Democratic Nomination.