No. Almost all the guys on your list have a higher completion percentage than him, he is demonstrably NOT better.
Completions yes, wins no. In the end it is about the W not how you look. Poor Romo, big bad gunslinger but yet cannot seem to win when it counts. Being a winner is more important than being good.
The reason Brady will be the #1 all time QB, not his completion rate but he will win more SB’s than anyone else.