[saganite]

True believers. Krivit makes valid points. It’s not an independently verified test but more of Rossi’s manipulation of observers to a test he controlled. I place a hell of a lot more confidence in what Krivit has to say than another dog and pony show by Rossi.

[Kevmo]

I place a hell of a lot more confidence in what Krivit has to say than another dog and pony show by Rossi.
***Actually, your skeptopathic cognitive dissonance is blinding you from seeing that you’re stacking up a guy like Krivit (basically an english major, no scientific training) against the 7 professional scientists who wrote the independent report.

[PapaBear3625]

Here’s what I want to see:

1) A test conducted at a lab of an independent scientist; and

2) Where Rossi only supplies that reactor cylinder plus any power module needed; and

3) The device’s power module is run off the lab’s outlet, with the independent scientist supplying the equipment which measure’s power input; and

4) The device operating inside a calorimeter which can accurately measure heat output; and

5) The test running at least 48 hours.

This stuff has been happening for several years at this point, with no product and no really independent tests.

[Rockingham]

Residual skepticism is in order, but not adamant disbelief. Although the precise mechanism is uncertain and the details of the materials undisclosed, if, as is claimed, the inputs were properly monitored, this third party verification of a sustained, massively disproportionate output of heat in this model E-Cat is a major step forward for Rossi.