[agere_contra]

If the murder happens then God knows about it. Moreover, being outside of time He knows about it before the fact.

But if the murderer never existed - or rather if that act of murder never existed - how could God know about it?

[stuartcr]

The aborter will exist and the aborted will have existed, right?

Earlier, I said that God knew who was going to have abortions 1000yrs before they happened and you said...’God cannot *know* what your acts of Free Will are going to be unless you are alive and in the world.’...You responded that God knew when you were going to die, even before you were born.

Does that mean that, before you are born, God knows when you will die, but not what you’re going to do?

Does that also mean that God doesn’t know about aborted children until after they have been aborted?