I’m amazed at how many electoral modes the Framers considered, rejected, reconsidered . . .
I would consider any mode other than direct, popular election. Electors by Congressional district works for me.
In 1800, Thomas Jefferson argued that Virginia should switch from its then-existing district system of electing presidential electors to the statewide winner-take-all system because of the political disadvantage suffered by states that divided their electoral votes by districts in a political environment in which other states used the winner-take-all approach:
while 10. states chuse either by their legislatures or by a general ticket [winner-take-all], it is folly & worse than folly for the other 6. not to do it. [Spelling and punctuation as per original]
Indeed, the now-prevailing statewide winner-take-all system became entrenched in the political landscape in the 1830s precisely because dividing a states electoral votes diminishes the states political influence relative to states employing the statewide winner-take-all approach.