American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[silent_jonny]

Jessica Sanchez
(3rd Song)

Iovine's choice is The Jackson Five's "I'll Be There".

BORING.

It's not bad, it just goes nowhere.

Steven: Pefect song, perfect chorus. You nailed it!

J-Lo: Perfect tone in your voice. You almost sounded like Michael. A little like Jermaine in one little part (whoa--a Jermaine burn)

Randy: I liked it, I didn't love it. There was never a "moment" moment. I would have prefered if you did the Mariah verison. (audience is booing) Can't I have an opinion?

Seacrest: It depends on what the opinion is.

That sounds familiar.

[CASchack]

You can also make a case for P2, with his pistol-packing father.

The odd man out is Joshua Obama.

[Shelayne]

Former Disney Star who went into treatment for an eating disorder and cutting. She used to date Joe Jonas of the Jonas Brothers. *pause for Ferlie scream* She was the star of “Camp Rock”, which was big with the tweens. I know, as I had two at the time. Oy.

[RummyChick]

They had to pick a small venue because she wouldn’t have the same kind of crowds

[dfwgator]

Former Disney Star who went into treatment for an eating disorder and cutting.

She's also a coke head.

[retrokitten]

The gossip blogs (roving gangs of ninja teens force me to read them) say Demi is still a mess in many, many ways.

Oh and I read that the rehab center she went to last year is just south of me on Route 83 in Lemont, IL. I didn’t even know there was a rehab center there.

[Shelayne]

I love this song!

[silent_jonny]

Are they trying to put us to sleep?

[peggybac]

I’d love to see P2 with a tan. He’d really be hot.

[retrokitten]

I love old Bob Segar. I’m so glad he finally released all his stuff digitally.

[slugbug]

LOL yeah he is a bit pale...I still think he’s a cutie!

[Shelayne]

That’s too bad.

P2 is really rubbing that thigh. Methinks he’s a little nervous without his guitar.

[twin2]

I think the Ferlies will love P2 on this one.

[retrokitten]

Yeah, he does appear to be nocturnal.

[peggybac]

Millions of girls were wishing they were rubbing his thigh.

[Clint N. Suhks]

Vote? Moi? Oh hell no! I let the 12 year old chickies decide for Nigel Lythgoe, serves him right putting it in their hands.

[retrokitten]

It reminded me of when Simon used to rubs his man-jugs.

[MagUSNRET]

Steve: “It doesnt matter if you hit the notes or not.”?????????

Well if that is the case...screw the singing, and let the yelping begin! (What an idiot)

[peggybac]

Revenge is on!!!!

[Miss Didi]

Yeah, orange is not a good color on him. It reflects on his skin and makes him look Oompa Loompa-y.

Or a giant Creamsicle. :)