Posted on 10/17/2011 6:51:30 AM PDT by decimon
lols.
And today, probably an accepted lifestyle; one eulogized by the “gay” community.
The establishment media lies?!?! Say it ain’t so. I am totally disillusioned.
The whole concept of “repressed memories” was BS from the get=go, and obviously so. Either you remember something or you don’t.
I don’t know the details; but, I believe establishing ‘bi-polar’ status as a disability helps get your ticket punched for free housing and even tuition assistance...maybe through SSA.
All I remember is that Sally Field was very impressive in the movie. Just one man’s opinion, and I was probably in my teens then.
Uh huh.... How do we know this isn't just personality #17 emerging?
I read this article yesterday but I think this story was debunked years ago.
Sunday NYTimes book review ignores books by Ann Coulter and Thomas Sowell but has time to review editor Jill Abramson’s dumb book about...her dog.
I beileve in repressed memories only in the vein that you “don’t seem to remember the event”, but if someone who was there suddenly comes along and asks you about it, you will remember clearly.
That is, you remember some stuff clearly but it just never comes to mind unless someone brings it up. And if nobody ever brings it up, well, it never comes up - so you have “repressed” the memory.
The “blackout” of memories (where even when it IS brought up, you still don’t remember) is another thing. I don’t buy that.
My first marriage ended due to the “repressed memory” thing. I remember a counselor saying he was concerned that, with the exception of a single instance, could not remember my parents “spanking” me. Then I asked my mother if she ever spanked me and she brought up the exact same occurance (on her own) as the only time.
So much for “repressed” memories and identifiying the counselor as a quack.
Witch-Hunt alert.
That’s the role that put Field on the map. An amazing performance. The fact that it’s comletely fictional a story doesn’t mean that the movie doesn’t have power. It certainly works as a horror story and Field was terrific!
However, even when it first came out, I had serious doubts.
And you can't trust the Diagnostic & Statistical Manual. Anything that keeps changing definitions of mental illnesses to suit the current political winds is, by unchanging definition, Stalinist.
“I beileve in repressed memories only in the vein that you ‘don’t seem to remember the event’, but if someone who was there suddenly comes along and asks you about it, you will remember clearly.”
You wouldn’t have been repressing it, then. That’s garden variety remembering. If it were what we’re talking about, you’d need not “someone who was there” but a highly trained genius brain excavator, i.e. a psychiatrist, to dig in your head and tell you what you don’t know about yourself.
“That is, you remember some stuff clearly but it just never comes to mind unless someone brings it up. And if nobody ever brings it up, well, it never comes up - so you have ‘repressed’ the memory”
This has nothing to with the subject at hand, really. People not bringing it up doesn’t constitute repression.
That's what I keep asking myself.
Of course this multiple personalities stuff is BS.
No it isn’t
Yes it is.
Shut up!!!
I can attest to the reality of "blacked-out" memories. There are three traumatic events in my life that I can remember before and after, but not during. And knowing what surrounded them, I'm really glad I don't remember the "during."
Have a friend who was repeatedly sexually abused by her dad (no doubt) from very early on. She did ‘repress’ very many memories, which only began to come back as she began to deal with what happened to her. She only ever had one personality, tho. If you don’t want to remember something, you sure enough can ‘repress’ it by choosing to forget it.
b
“Witch-Hunt alert”
This may be a joke, but if you actually read Freud, Jung, etc. they go beyond the mere self-protection of individual psyche to posit horror at the origin of human culture. That is to say, we are neurotics not only because our parents had sex in front of us when we were babies, but also because we can dimly remember people practicing human sacrifice 65,000 years ago, or something. Which is insane, but, hey, what is psychology for?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.