James Durbin
His choice is "While My Guitar Gently Weeps".
Jimmy and Will aren't impressed. "While My Guitar Gently Sleeps", says Jimmy.
But James wants to take a chance.
Does it pay off?
It's okay. Stringed intruments and an electric guitar (of course) accompany him.
At the end, James wipes his eyes. 
J-Lo: It's nice to see that other side of you. So special to watch. Special that you're vulnerable enough to share it with us.
Randy: The emotional side of James Durbin. You have to take chances in order to be an artist. Extremely important. Very nice. Very nice.
Steven: Not only did your guitar gently weep, so did you.
*vomit*
A drinking game could be made on how many times the words "vulnerable" and "emotional" are used here. Seacrest gets all Barbara Walters on James, trying to make him burst into tears.
For the drama manipulation: 
Behind the scenes footage, James again stresses how emotional this was for him. Okay, okay! We get it! Your senthative!
