Well, Haley is pretty and she definitely has a powerful voice. When she’s not at the top of her lungs ( ie the first 30 secs of each song) she has a unique tone.
But she is blowing her opportunity to be real. She doesn’t believe her songs. She smiles and vamps. She is sexy. She’s got that going for her. But she doesn’t make the most of her songs. And she gets too intense for so long. I’d love to see her reach intensity and then bring her voice back to that unusual tone she has.
I think the judges were onto her weaknesses after the first song, but then they went nuts for her after the new Orleans song. She ruined the dark warning of that amazing song, but they worshipped her.
My thoughts from last night:
James - He was off. But its his first off night so he gets a pass.
Jacob - Go home! Please go home, you blubbering baby
Haley - I just like looking at you. You sing good too, but not as good as Lauren.
Scotty - Meh
Lauren - Good night for her. Looks, voice, the whole package. She and James should be in the final
Judges - Once again they sucked.