[RummyChick]

Chester Arthur , a Republican, had one parent born in Ireland who was naturalized but NOT AT THE TIME OF HIS BIRTH and one parent born in the US. Arthur claimed he was born in the US.

Under these facts-He was elected President.

Did anyone come forward to define NBC or send it to SCOTUS or do anything????

They might have had he been born elsewhere.

Obama is in a similar situation - except he was born a bastard.

[Godebert]

"Chester Arthur , a Republican, had one parent born in Ireland who was naturalized but NOT AT THE TIME OF HIS BIRTH and one parent born in the US. Arthur claimed he was born in the US. Under these facts-He was elected President."

What evidence do you have that those "facts" were known when he was elected?