'Jeopardy' to pit humans against IBM machine

Associated Press ^ | 12-13-10 | DAVID BAUDER

[TheZMan]

Ugh, always worries me when people do this kind of thing. It gives the uninitiated the false impression that there is such a thing as “real” AI.

[NonValueAdded]

while Jennings and Rutter said they would give half of their prize money away.

I believe that is called "taxes." I'll take "25%" for 1,000,000 Alex.

[Avery Iota Kracker]

Why not just have a computer do what Alex does, that would be easy. I’m sure it would do just as good a job, and not look smug while doing it.

[Future Snake Eater]

So what do they do with “Watson”? Hook a Cat5 into it, and have it Google every Jeopardy question? Chess is one thing—there are moves and counter-moves to study and predict. Jeopardy is just straight factoid knowledge.

[Morpheus2009]

Perhaps it’s like the computer that took voice commands from Scotty in the original Star Trek Series

[Charles Henrickson]

'Jeopardy' to pit humans against IBM machine

I propose an even greater challenge:

[econjack]

I agree. This is more of a database interface issue than anything else.

[The Cajun]

In the Jeopardy format, puter will kick their ass.

[screaminsunshine]

Open the door Hal.

[shibumi]

"Ugh, always worries me when people do this kind of thing. It gives the uninitiated the false impression that there is such a thing as “real” AI."

The enemies of free markets, open societies, free worship, public expression of faith and ultimately free thinking itself have always had a vested interest in reducing the perception of human intelligence to synapses, relays bit and bytes.

Along with fellow travelers in the Humanist movement, atheists like B.F. Skinner have reveled in the notion that man and his society could be reduced to the soulless responses of machine like patterned behavior. The goal of demonstrations such as these is a thinly veiled attempt to push man's conception of himself into that void foreshadowed in Skinner's "Beyond Freedom And Dignity."

Sorry, but I, along with most of the Conservative FRiends I have on this site will keep both - the freedom and the dignity - along with our souls.

[Bullish]

Danger! Will Robinson!

[ModelBreaker]

Well, it would have to understand the subject and the question. So there’s a lot of text analysis and comprehension required (very difficult) and then it has to access it’s knowledge base for an answer, pick the correct answer, and phrase it as a question.

Not really so easy with a computer. What helps is the rigid format of Jeopardy questions.

[Moose Burger]

I guess it’s about natural language parsing. It’s one thing for a computer to solve “SELECT max(age) FROM xvii_century WHERE country IN europe etc...” and another to understand “This NFL quarterback is a great-great-great-grandson of Brigham Young” well enough to look for the answer.

[BigCinBigD]

What is...Judgment Day?

Correct!

I’ll take bad ideas in science for a Thousand, Alex.

[Ditto]

This is more of a database interface issue than anything else.

I'm thinking search terms and connection speed.

[Moose Burger]

Yes, that’s it: Designing a computer that can process and understand natural language http://www.research.ibm.com/deepqa/

[Strk321]

I dunno, but Deep Blue sure made a fool out of Kasparov. He used to be interested in computer chess, but not after that. He should have played some old Windows 3.0 programs like GNU Chess and Winchess. Those things had amazingly stupid AIs.

Actually, the chess program included with Windows 7 is just as stupid, but the graphics are better.

[Tucker39]

As one of the last GIs to use Morse Code in military communication, it was of great interest to me about a month ago when some outfit held a contest between two guys communicating via Morse, and two other guys using cell phones to send text messages. The two teams were given identical messages to send back and forth.

The two guys using Morse did not use a standard telegraph key, but rather a semi-automatic mechanical speed device we called a “Bug” in the Army. The Morse Code guys got their messages sent back and forth, and then “had time for a sandwich” before the texters were finished! Hopefully the contest with “Watson” will have a similar outcome. Hoooaahh!!

[Moose Burger]

I remember that Kasparov used to play versus Fritz.