Irvine Community and Jewish Groups React to Muslim Student Union Suspension

PajamasMedia ^ | 24 June, 2010 | Reut R. Cohen

[Salem]

The University of California, Irvine (UCI) is the second youngest campus in the California state university system. UCI has made its mark among prestigious American universities, steadily rising in the U.S. News & World Report ratings of “America’s Best Colleges.” Following the al-Qaeda terror attacks on September 11, 2001, however, the prestigious and relatively subdued Orange County campus began drawing attention and earning a reputation as a breeding ground for anti-American, anti-Israel, and anti-Semitic sentiment.

At UCI, certain registered student groups, while claiming to exercise rights to free speech, have violated state and university policy. This is particularly true of the Muslim Student Union (MSU), which is part of the national network of the Muslim Students Association (MSA). The organization, more than any other campus group, is known for its seditious rhetoric and hostile, militant activities. Several students and faculty have reported feeling intimidated or even frightened in the presence of MSU members. Such victims have often chosen to remain silent rather than oppose campus organizations whose confrontational tactics and agendas were, over recent years, increasingly tolerated by the university administration and community. As a result of its members’ belligerent and sometimes violent behavior, Irvine’s MSU has rendered itself among the most severely hostile Muslim student organizations in North America.

That is why UCI’s latest move, which was initially publicized by the Jewish Federation of Orange County, has attracted particular interest. UCI’s administration made an unprecedented decision to suspend the MSU for a full year. The decision was made after a school investigation found that the organization planned disruptions during a February speech by Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren. The decision to suspend the group was not so much about the fact that the MSU disrupted a speech, but that the group later lied about its intentions and actions.

The suspension, if appeals by the Muslim Student Union are unsuccessful, will take effect during the 2010-2011 school term. The chapter will also be required to complete 50 hours of community service before it is able to file appropriate paperwork to have the organization reinstated. If the group is successful in that procedure, it will, however, face a year of disciplinary probation following reinstatement.

In a letter dated May 27, 2010, Senior Executive Director of Student Housing Lisa Cornish detailed the findings of the school investigation. The 14 pages detail that the MSU violated four separate school policies involving dishonesty, obstructing disciplinary procedures, disorderly conduct, and “participation in a disturbance of the peace of unlawful assembly.” These violations transpired during a talk given by Michael Oren on February 8. His remarks were interrupted at least 10 different times by students, including those who repeated the tiresome canard of an Israeli genocide and who shouted accusations that Oren was a murderer and a war criminal. Oren briefly suspended his talk, resuming it only after school officials tried to restore order and repeatedly advised the audience that the outbursts violated student conduct codes.

Prior to the disturbance of the event, UCI officials were notified that there was an organized plan to disrupt the speech. The Investigative Project on Terrorism cited emails in which an MSU official wrote:

“We’ve already discussed the different options in the GA (general assembly) meeting and we took a vote,” a February 4 email to the MSU board said. “So now that we have voted on one method of action, we all go through this together, insha’Allah ta’ala together as one MSU … one Ummah.”

Officers from the MSU denied that their protest at the Oren event was an organized effort, stating that actions were carried out by individuals and were not on behalf of the MSU. In particular, MSU President Mohamed Abdelgany wrote the following:

I would first like to say that all of my actions on Monday were done out of my own individual accord and were not on behalf of the Muslim Student Union or any other organization at UC Irvine.

The spokesperson for the MSU, Hadeer Soliman, went on the record with the Los Angeles Times stating that the disruption “was not put on by the MSU, but rather by students acting on their own.” Soliman made the same claim in an editorial written for UCI’s official school paper. Screenshots of MSU emails are available on the Investigative Project for Terrorism website.

UCI’s investigation concluded that “the disruptions were planned, orchestrated and coordinated by the Muslim Student Union.” Furthermore, a spokesperson for the university, Cathy Lawhon, also noted that the members of panel which conducted the inquiry “have had no prior issues with the group.” Cornish’s letter also cites the February 3 MSU meeting in which a stated goal was to send sending Oren a message “that he knows that he can’t just go to a campus and say whatever he wants” by “push[ing] the envelope.”

The MSU issued a statement that the group plans to appeal the university’s recommendation of suspension. The group maintains that the students who disrupted Oren “acted in their personal capacity.”

In her letter, Cornish said MSU members invoked their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination in response to her questions. Cornish also noted that there were several occasions during the Oren event in which MSU members were warned to stop.

The move to suspend the MSU over this recent incident has been welcomed by some in both the UC and wider Jewish communities. Shalom Elcott, the president of the Jewish Federation, expressed approval for the administration’s decision on the official blog of the Jewish Federation of Orange County:

“We commend the University for its judicious decision in support of free speech and civil discourse,” he said. “The University’s disciplinary action regarding the MSU establishes an important and appropriate precedent and sends a powerful message to other universities across the nation.”

In contrast, the Zionist Organization of America (ZOA) commended the decision while asserting that it was long overdue. “While the ZOA has commended the university for finally taking action, we believe that sanctioning the MSU was long overdue,” said Susan Tuchman, the director of the Zionist Organization of America’s Center for Law and Justice. “For years now, the ZOA and others have identified numerous instances where the MSU had violated university policies. We’d repeatedly called on the administration to enforce its own policies and punish the wrongdoers, but that didn’t happen.”

In October 2004, the ZOA expressed concern about the MSU’s pattern of hatred in action. After several concerned Jewish students filed reports alleging anti-Semitic harassment, the ZOA initiated a Title VI complaint with the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) in the U.S. Department of Education on behalf of Jewish students at UCI. The ZOA had attempted to use diplomacy to address the hostility on campus, but UCI administrators ignored their efforts, prompting the organization to turn to Title VI. “There were many instances of misconduct by the MSU that the ZOA, students, and others had repeatedly brought to the UCI administration’s attention,” explained Tuchman. “These incidents were either ignored or whitewashed by the administration. For example, university policies expressly prohibited harassment based on religion or ethnicity (among other things), which creates a hostile or intimidating campus environment. Student after student reported to us that they’d complained to the UCI administration about anti-Semitic hostility on the campus, and that their complaints were essentially ignored. UCI’s policies prohibit physical assault or other conduct that threatens a person’s health or safety.”

Tuchman said she was receiving troubling complaints from students that they were being assaulted or feeling threatened, and that their grievances were neglected by administrators and police.

In its report, the OCR found that complaints dating back several years, including documented instances where rocks were thrown by MSU members at a Jewish student and the destruction of a Holocaust memorial in 2003, did not contribute to a hostile environment on campus because they “constitute isolated acts that were unrelated to the timely alleged acts.” Because the complaint with the OCR was filed over 180 days after the incidents in question occurred, they were disregarded in the investigation. In other instances, OCR investigators found that university officials acted appropriately or that the complaint could not be conclusively identified as anti-Semitic. For example, a swastika found in a bathroom in the Social Ecology building was not considered anti-Semitic because there was a vulgar phrase directed against Asians in the same bathroom and the OCR could not ascertain whether the swastika was referring to Asians or Jews.

The OCR decision suggested that Title VI did not apply to Jewish students as a racial or national origin group. The decision did, however, spark concern from members of Congress. Members of the House also asked whether OCR’s policy for enforcing Title VI was affording Jewish students the protections they deserved. The criticism from members of the House and Senate likely compelled the OCR to re-evaluate the case. On April 25, 2008, a letter to the ZOA from the OCR indicated that it planned to launch a new investigation into the incidents that occurred at UCI. The OCR determined after its first report that several of the ZOA’s allegations were “appropriate for investigation under the laws enforced by OCR.” Although more than two years have passed, there has been no conclusion to the case.

A group of local citizens in the Irvine area started a group to investigate anti-Semitism at UC Irvine. The group was comprised of various academic, professional, and religious leaders, and had Jewish and non-Jewish members. It became known as the Orange County Independent Task Force on Anti-Semitism (OC Task Force) and its goal was “to study, investigate, and issue a report on alleged incidents of racism and anti-Semitism at the University of California – Irvine (UCI).”

The OC Task Force also stated: “We are not singling out any specific group. We are looking at all instances of alleged anti-Semitic and racist activity.” After mounting an investigation in which students, faculty, and other key witnesses were interviewed, the OC Task Force released a report in December 2007. The report’s findings demonstrated a troubling pattern of anti-Semitism on the part of the MSU that was ignored or even, in some cases, justified by the UCI administration. The OC Task Force’s most serious recommendation was for “Jewish students to consider enrolling in other universities.” The report can be read in its entirety on the official website for the OC Task Force.

Responding to the recent suspension of the MSU, Ted Bleiweis, executive director of the group, was more cautious than many in the UCI community who have commended the suspension recommendation. “The evidence presented in the May 27, 2010, letter from UC Irvine to MSU officials appears to demonstrate an organized and deliberate attempt by the MSU to stifle Ambassador Oren’s First Amendment right to free speech and the audience’s right to hear what he had to say,” said Bleiweis. “It remains to be seen if the administration will actually follow through on its recommended action. In addition, keep in mind that until the appeals process has been completed, it is premature to draw any conclusions about the outcome.”

Gary Fouse, an adjunct teacher at the university, has blogged about the situation on campus for several years. He suggested that the disruption of the Oren event has opened the eyes of many in the community. “This incident made so many people realize that there was a problem at UCI in spite of the denials by the university and groups like the OC Jewish Federation,” he said. “Many in the local community, including ACT for America, got involved. They held meetings. They wrote letters to [UC President] Yudof and [UCI Chancellor] Drake. They demanded action.”

Fouse also cautioned against believing the suspension of the MSU will solve issues on campus. “I look for the MSU members to do things under other sympathetic student groups.” Fouse also believes that the issues on campus are far more extensive than a squabble between Muslims and Jews. “The issue is bigger. It concerns everybody,” said Fouse.

Reut Cohen graduated from UCI, where she ran a blog to document the anti-Israel, anti-Semitic, and anti-American incidents on campus.

[Salem]

For those who have been on this list for a number of years, you will remember the debriefing of my trip to UCI in 2007 to meet Daniel Pipes. Reut Cohen was the young lady who took the initiative to follow the MSU thugs outside after they disrupted Pipes' talk and recorded the hateful things they said.

She is a dynamic example of the new American Jewish youth standing strong in the face of Islamist hate. Her article here proves that with steady opposition to Islamic coercion and intimidation, we can turn the tide against the MSU and CAIR.

[Salem]

---

If you'd like to be on or off this
Christian Supporters of Israel ping list,
please FR mail me ~
    

There failed not ought of any good thing which the LORD had
spoken unto the house of Israel; all came to pass. (Joshua 21:45)
Free Republic does not suffer criticism of Jewry ... Stormfront
Letter To The President In Support Of Israel ~
'Final Solution,' Phase 2 ~
Warnings ~
The Nature Of Bruce ~

Pray For The Peace Of Jerusalem [FR]
The Joshua Fund
The Jerusalem Connection
Christians United For Israel
Christian Friends of Israel
Jerusalem Watchman

"The West has given more significance to the myth of the genocide of the Jews, even more significant than God, religion, and the prophets...."—Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad
The Holocaust Chronicle ~
" ... It's time we recognized the nature of the conflict. It's total war and we are all involved. Nobody on our side is exempted because of age, gender, or handicap. The Islamofacists have stolen childhood from the world."—FReeper Retief
"Palestine is the wrong name for their State. It should be called Anarchy."—FReeper sgtbono2002
"Then let's wait and see what the Arabs do after they take Gaza. There's nothing like Arab reality to break up a Jewish fantasy."—FReeper Noachian
A student told his professor he was going to "Palestine" to "fight for freedom, peace and justice,"—Orwellian leftist code words that mean "murder Jews."

[LouAvul]

relatively subdued Orange County campus began drawing attention and earning a reputation as a breeding ground for anti-American, anti-Israel, and anti-Semitic sentiment

Orange County? When I was still living in kalifornia OC was conservative. When are we going to stop allowing these raghead mother humping cockroaches into our country?

[doc1019]

Mayhap when we get a president that didn’t spend his formative years memorizing the Koran in a Muslim country?

[SunkenCiv]

Following the al-Qaeda terror attacks on September 11, 2001, however, the prestigious and relatively subdued Orange County campus began drawing attention and earning a reputation as a breeding ground for anti-American, anti-Israel, and anti-Semitic sentiment. At UCI, certain registered student groups, while claiming to exercise rights to free speech, have violated state and university policy. This is particularly true of the Muslim Student Union (MSU), which is part of the national network of the Muslim Students Association (MSA). The organization, more than any other campus group, is known for its seditious rhetoric and hostile, militant activities. Several students and faculty have reported feeling intimidated or even frightened in the presence of MSU members.

[EDINVA]

I lived in Newport Beach in the late 70’s when it was a white upper middle class enclave. By the time I returned in the mid-80s it had become heavily laden with Iranians; presumably other Middle Easterners settled in the area over the years. I find it appalling that these people who sought refuge in the US assume such a hostile attitude to their gracious host communities.

[AldebaranOnAltair]

You may be interested to know that there are two “Mosques” in Orange County within a few miles of each other and just a few miles from Irvine.

[LouAvul]

Now that you mention it, I remember when that idiot carter was prez the ragheads were protesting and rioting cause they know jimmy limp wrist wouldn't lift a finger.

Then Reagan became Commander in Chief and suddenly the camel humpers went quiet.

[MadMax, the Grinning Reaper]

Look for the MSU to operate thru a local chapter of the marxist National Lawyers Guild, any anti-Israel coalition, ANSWER/IAC, Party of Socialism and Liberation, or even one of the “green” groups/parties, as well as any other Moslem group on campus or near it, including CAIR.

Keep the spotlight on these termites.

[Squawk 8888]

The problem isn’t the immigrants, it’s their locally-born kids. We have similar problems here in Canada where muslim immigrants are fiercely loyal to their adopted country, but their children, having never experienced life in an Islamic state, turn into jihadis.

[M Kehoe]

Good evening. I hope you are doing well.

I don't think it was a good idea to ban the muslim student union. Nor do I think it's a good idea to ban any radical muslim group. No matter what their hate. Why?

So that we can find, and eliminate them when it comes time. Oh, there will be a time...

5.56mm

[EDINVA]

So where are the 1st generation Canadians/Americans learning all the hate? Some may be in a mosque, or MSA’s, but there has to be some coming from home, too.

It’s fantastic that UCI is taking this step. Maybe some of our other universities will take a clue. I hope the decision-makers stay safe.

[Squawk 8888]

The Saudis are the primary source; most mosques in North America are Saudi-funded and controlled, and they bring in clerics whose mission is to radicalize the locals.

[EDINVA]

Yes, and I live within (a healthy) walking distance of the Islamic Saudi Academy. Ain’t life grand?

[SJackson]

Middle East and terrorism, occasional political and Jewish issues Ping List. High Volume

If you’d like to be on or off, please FR mail me.

..................

[dervish]

Thank you.

I am glad there are people like Reut Cohen, but I think she is the exception. Frank Luntz did a study demonstrating how Jewish students on campus often do nothing to defend Israel.

That is why two groups - Stand With Us and the David Project have developed programs to teach students how to respond to anti-Israel attacks.

http://www.standwithus.com/ABOUT/

http://www.thedavidproject.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=frontpage&Itemid=1

[Salem]

Thanks!  

[Salem]

"Orange County? When I was still living in kalifornia OC was conservative. "

It still is. UC Irvine is a different country these days. Kind of like the Arizona border of academia.