Does Kurt Warner deserve a spot in the NFL Hall of Fame?

01.30.10 | Perdogg

[Perdogg]

The following 7 QBs are in the Hall of fame; Troy Aikman, Dan Fouts, Terry Bradshaw, John Elway, Joe Montana, Warren Moon, Steve Young.

Cumulative passer rating Regular season: 83.03
Cumulative passer rating Post season: 85.32
Cumulative passer rating: 83.22


14 Super Bowl win out of 17 starts. Fouts and Warren did not play in a Super Bowl.

Warner passer rating Regular season: 93.71
Warner passer rating Post season: 102.84
Warner passer rating: 94.64


1 Super Bowl win out of 3 starts.


Yards - Aikmann - 36,791
Yards - Fouts - 45,165
Yards - Bradshaw - 31,822
Yards - Elway - 56,439
Yards - Montana - 46,363
Yards - Moon - 52,195
Yards - Young - 36,450


Yards - Warner - 36,296

[RayChuang88]

Despite what some people think, Warner will get into the Hall of Fame using what I call the Colin Cowherd test--can you describe the athlete's greatness in one sentence?

I can sum up Warner's career thus: he brought greatness to two downtrodden franchises. Good enough for me!

[Perdogg]

Jim Plunkett is the only two-time winner who is not in the Hall of Fame.

[cleveland gop]

If there are still doubts about Kurt being a first ballot HOF’er, this ought to clear it up...
COMPLETION PERCENTAGE OF 65.5%!!!

And how many of those were little 5 yard dump off passes? Very few. Kurt took more chances down the field than most. Sure he had plenty of great receivers to make the athletic catch, but more often than not, those passes were accurately thrown!!

[Round 9]

Namath doesn’t deserve the HOF. In fact his career numbers are pretty pitiful!

173 td’s
220 int’s
50.1% completions
65.5 career QB rating

He’s another overrated NY media creation. In fact he doesn’t belong in the top 100 all time QB’s.

[CSM]

I thought it was the “Pro Football Hall of Fame.” However, I could be mistaken. For his “rags to riches” story alone, I am all for it.