The show *could* survive without Simon, but if they replace him with someone disgusting I want even watch or host the thread.
Good point -- let's withhold judgment. Who do you think might make a good judge? Fred Willard maybe? Robin Williams (hos shtick is a bit old, though)? Phil Spector broadcasting from his prison cell?
Don Rickles would be great in the ELLEN seat...but as far as a musical expert...Im thinking....David Foster..??