/johnny
ping for your comments
I really don't have any words of advise for LiIon batteries because they don't seem to have the same pickiness about charging the other two had.
I will say don't expect the $40 battery to last as long as your original. You might get lucky, but every time I've gotten a cheap battery off of eBay it wasn't even worth what I paid for it. I have bought good batteries for 60-70% of the OEM retail price, but when you get below half price they generally don't have the life claimed or last the number of recharge cycles.
If you used it in the intended manner, it might not fail for 2 or 3 years, and then you wouldn't have to go through the hassle of abusing your warranty rights.
I’m no expert, but if I recall correctly, lithium-ion battery life is tied to the number of charging cycles, not how deep the battery is discharged. Bottom line, to maximize life you should run plugged in as much as possible and only run off the battery when you really need to.
Again...I think this is correct, but I could be wrong.
We have 3 laptops in our house. One is a Sager that I purchased 9/04, the next is a Toshiba Tablet PC purchased in 2006, and the last is a generic Toshiba for the wife in early 2008.
My first Sager battery was dead in about 7 months. Then I was told, since I leave it on nearly 24x7 (as we do all 3), to remove the battery, and only charge it once a month.
That has served us well, and we haven’t had a battery issue since, although, I did have to buy a new AC adapter for my Sager. (it runs real hot)
Good luck.