Then tonight, before you to bed, be sure to check the lock on each door and window in your house at least 10 times. And whatever you do, don't go near any vehicle; especially cars, trucks, boats, trains or planes. You just never know.
Seriously, disabling protective software for a short time while you investigate performance issues is highly unlikely to get you infected. It may allow currently existing malware to phone home, but if the malware was already able to get itself installed, and is responsible for your current problem, your protective software isn't worth much anyway. Anti-virus software and firewalls aren't the best way to keep your computer infection free. Keeping kids away from your computer is.
Make fun if you want, but please unplug if you want to be safe. Two years ago I was rebuilding my father-in-laws XP system. The installation disk came with SP1, but SP2 wasn’t in place. I thought I’d go ahead and download SP2 before I got the virus software in place. It took all of 45 minutes for a worm to infect the beast. I had to wipe the drive and reinstall.
Take a look at your router history some time. There are probes from the wild internet CONSTANTLY. I run a web site and I have to monitor the logs. I only allow SSL input authenticated by WEBAUTH/Kerberos. (I also beat on my user base about the strength of their passwords.) Most probes are somewhat benign, but many are looking for specific weaknesses. Why take a chance when unplugging is so easy?
That is only true if you have a router acting as a firewall that you plug into for the internet.
Otherwise, you will be pwned in under ten minutes.