"Why should we make the mistake of fighting the current revolution with the tools & tactics of prior conflicts?"
Mistake? Tell that to those who fought, and won The American Revolutionary War, or those who defeated Hitler.
"The biggest crime is not that it's illegal to advocate treason & sedition, but because it's ineffective."
You make the mistake of assuming that anyone on this board is advocating sedition or treason.
The treason is already being committed, by the Socialist Democrats and their Dear Leader, in case you hadn't noticed.
And, for your information, the American people have every right to uphold, defend, and protect the Constitution of The United States of America against all enemies, both foreign and domestic.
There's a reason for the 2nd Amendment, my friend, and it's got nothing to do with hunting dinner. It's for hunting treasonous politicians and would-be tyrants.
Don't you really want to win? Why would you reject, or fail to consider, such an effective means of victory that could easily garner the support of 100m or so Americans in a unified effort?
Or do you really want to win? Ever hear of the term "agent provocateur"? Why would you advocate something that is both ineffective and strengthens the hand of the enemy?