Posted on 02/01/2009 11:42:01 PM PST by Swordmaker
Actually, from the virus info posted on this thread it sounds like Windows machines would be safe if running Firefox.
The problem is that the IT people in the school system are unionized, so even if the “educators” knew how to scrub them the work rules prohibit them from doing so. Ditto for the students- the union would be up in arms if they showed the students how to fix the problem.
You've described most school board computer networks to a tee.
My local school system has 30,00 networked windows computers, and none of them runs with supervisor priveleges. You can't install anything.
30,00 = 30,000
Sorry to hear that.....unions are counterproductive for a country’s prosperity....they once had their place to protect workers, now it’s about politics and a cash cow from dues to donate to socialist candidates and support the union bosses.
But since it's not their money . . .
“A locked-down computer with automatic updates installed shouldn’t need anti-virus software.”
Unfortunately, this is NOT true if the computer is running Windows and Microsoft’s Internet Explorer. You can be fully up to date and still be exploited by a rogue ad on a normally trustworthy web page.
Been there, done that.
Yeah, the school system I work for doesn’t allow students or teachers to run executables. Which can be somewhat amusing if someone brings in a Sandisk thumb drive.
Cue the WinTards.
“But I can build a Windows Pee C for $122.35 from scraps of baling wire and duct tape. And I’ve never had any problems! Windows Rox!”
That's okay. The Windows System User will still run them.
I haven’t been in a school for a couple of years, but last time I checked each high school kid gets a bit of personal space on the server for documents. Homework is carried on floppy disks. Anyone bring in documents on non-standard media takes it to the Library (media center) for conversion to floppy disk.
Any project needing some special operating system or feature is done on an off-line computer. Any computer getting hosed by accident or vandalism gets re-imaged.
Of course, that assumes every machine will be connected to a fast network, but that's the case in most schools nowadays. And it would have intentional limitations (no local file storage, no installing of executables) that I wouldn't want in a home computer, but that are appropriate in a school environment.
The way I see it, in marketplace terms, Mac OS and Linux are allies. Anyone who chooses Linux benefits the Mac, and vise versa, by weakening the hegemony of Windows. Microsoft has maintained its market share largely through FUD, and anyone who switches -- no matter what they switch to -- weakens Windows and opens up more opportunities for all the alternatives. Opportunities the alternative OSes in days of yore like Amiga, Be, OS/2, DRDOS and NextStep never got.
I don't expect to see a world in which the Mac occupies the place once held by Windows, but a world in which no one does; where documents and Web pages are built to open standards, and any OS can play. We're a lot closer to that than we were ten years ago.
I’d replace the floppies with flash drives, but otherwise that model makes a lot of sense.
I dunno - it's been years since I've heard of any remote [& non-priveleged] rootings which weren't already covered by a Microsoft update.
Our security consists of a firewall and all users running in normal mode [NOT Administrator mode], and we've never had any worms or viruses in ten years now.
Of course, if you allow your users to run their systems in Administrator mode, then all bets are off - there's absolutely nothing whatsoever that can be done to stop a determined virus/worm when it comes in contact with a technically illiterate user running his system in Administrator mode.
But my experience has been that as long as you keep your users in User mode, then there's really not all that much to worry about.
Yes, if one has access to the command prompt and permission to run the AT command.
Those permissions are denied to end users on our domain.
We allow flash drives, but have filters set on the file server when it comes to data storage.
That's assuming that Windows works the way that Microsoft says it does.
Granted, most users don't have the know-how to work their way around such restrictions.
That's okay, the worm writers do.
Here, let me bring you up to date:
That one’s only two years old.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.