[dfwgator]

I dunno, does Miami even sniff the playoffs without Pennington? Yes Manning is better, but who was more valuable to their team?

[Military family member]

Look at the Colts' 3-4 start, when Peyton was struggling to overcome two surgeries, then see what happened when he got his rhythm back, 9-0.

I would say Manning is clearing the more valuable to his team than Pennington.

[Lou L]

I dunno, does Miami even sniff the playoffs without Pennington?

You could say the same thing about the Colts...a .500 season would be difficult without Peyton Manning.