Nah.....He was a heart-throb in his day. But the persona he portrayed was what I found attractive. He could be the cowboy, or dress in a tux and be appropriate in both worlds.
I can't imagine seeing one whom I thought was pretty back then.
Reminds me of my 10yr HS reunion. The gal who was voted "most changed" had been this cute, petite little cheerleader with blonde hair. All the girls were in awe of her and all the guys wanted to date her.
When she showed up at the reunion, she weighed no less than 300lbs on a 5ft frame. She'd married right out of HS and had 4 kids. No one recognized her.
I bet some guys felt that they had dodged a bullet.