Replies

Now Kerry Collins is the official worst QB in a Super Bowl.

Again, Craig Morton, if you are out there, I am sorry.

Rating

1 Phil Simms 150.92
2 Steve Young 134.08
3 Doug Williams 127.87
4 Joe Montanna 127.83
5 Jim Plunkett 122.83
6 Jake Delhomme 113.57
7 Terry Bradshaw 112.80
8 Troy Aikmann 111.93
9 Ken Stabler 111.73
10 Bart Starr 105.98
11 Jim Mcmahon 104.17
12 Bob Lee 104.17
13 Tom Brady 99.88
14 Bret Farve 97.61
15 Roger Staubach 95.37
16 Ken Anderson 95.22
17 Jeff Hostetler 93.49
18 Mark Rypien 91.98
19 Kurt Warner 89.12
20 Len Dawson 84.75
21 Joe Namath 83.33
22 Brad Johnson 82.77
23 Payton Manning 81.80
24 Trent Dilfer 80.92
25 Steve McNair 80.09
26 Donovan McNabb 75.37
27 Bob Griese 72.71
28 Daryle Lamonica 71.69
29 Vince Ferragamo 70.75
30 Rex Grossmann 68.30
31 Matt Hasselback 67.81
32 Dan Marino 66.92
33 Frank Reich 62.63
34 John Elway 59.32
35 Drew Bledsoe 58.77
36 Steve Groogan 57.22
37 Joe Theismann 57.11
38 Jim Kelly 56.94
39 Danny White 56.25
40 Stan Humphreys 56.08
41 Joe Kapp 52.58
42 Neal ODonnell 51.32
43 David Woodly 50.00
44 Ron Jawarski 49.34
45 Rich Gannon 48.86
46 Norris Weese 47.92
47 Chris Chandler 47.20
48 Boomer Esiason 46.08
49 Fran Tarkenton 43.70
50 Don Strock 39.58
51 Tony Eason 39.58
52 Johnny Unitas 34.66
53 Earl Morrall 24.74
54 Ben Roethlisberger 22.62
55 Craig Morton 20.02
56 Billy Kilmer 19.64
57 Kerry Collins 7.05

That looks good. A passer rating cant go negative either if I recall correctly. If you want to have fun go pull the stats from Rex Grossman in his last regular season game last year (against the Packers) and calculate his passer ratting in that game.

I have a bad feeling that Eli Manning is going to join his fellow Giants QB at the bottom of the list.