I believe the trainer. Why would he tell the truth about Andy Pettitte, but make up an elaborate lie about Clemens? There’s a guy on Comcast Philadelphia, named John Marzano. He’s a former backup catcher for the Red Sox in the early 90’s, now turned talking head for Comcast and MLB. They asked him about it, first he said the normal player CYA, can’t believe it, etc, etc, but then said if it was only B-12 and Lidocaine that was being injected, why was the personal trainer injecting it? These teams have doctors, that would have been the doctor’s job.
Brain McNamee said on tape to Roger Clemens, “The truth is the truth.” and Roger had no come-back.
Brian McNamee asked repeaatedly, what do you want me to do? Roger NEVER said — just admit that you didn’t tell the truth. Roger refused to answer the question.
The recorded telephone conversation tells the story. Brian McNamee knows he injected Clemens with HGH, and Roger knows it. They skirted it. If McNamee was lying, Roger would have confronted him. He didn’t.