Posted on 04/11/2007 11:27:24 AM PDT by TChris
Submerging computer chips in oil could make them more energy efficient, according to a UK company that hopes to start selling such systems within a year.
The microprocessors inside servers and desktop computers are normally cooled using fans that blow air across the components. But UK a company called Very-PC hopes to see a much more radical, oil-based alternative, take off instead.
"It is possible to cut power consumption in half," managing director Peter Hopton told New Scientist. "You don't need to drive inefficient fans, or the usual air conditioning."
Hopton first got the idea after seeing computer enthusiasts discuss the idea online. Oil does not affect the function of electronic components and offers a potentially useful cooling solution since it transports heats more efficiently than air.
Prototypes developed by the company demonstrate that placing server electronics in oil can dramatically reduce their electricity usage, by removing the need for traditional cooling systems.
Deep-fat server
In tests, server racks were immersed in tanks of oil normally used to keep machinery cool. A refrigeration unit positioned below was used to create convection currents that draw heat away from the electronics, which is much more energy efficient than using fans. "Using oil we could chill down to -20ºC, but between 0ºC and 10ºC looks to be best," says Hopton.
He suggests that the extra cost of using oil should be quickly paid back by the increased efficiency. Also, keeping components cooler should reduce the chances of failure, making the machines more reliable, Hopton says, and that more machines can be packed into the same amount of physical space.
Initial prototypes used motor oil until they realised this could corrode some of the components. The firm plans to have an oil-bath server prototype finished in the next few months, and plans to begin selling them early in 2008.
Why switch?
Suresh Garimella, an expert on electronics cooling at Purdue University in the US is not convinced. Although oil cooling is an established method for cooling electrical components, like transformers, he says a specialised dielectric cooling liquid, such as Fluorinert, has a tried–and-tested record and would be the fluid of choice.
For example, during the 1980s, components inside Cray 2 supercomputers were submerged in Fluorinert, created by US company 3M, for cooling purposes.
"I don't know why oil is being suggested for computer cooling instead of accepted dielectric fluids," says Garimella, who is not familiar with Very-PCs plans. "The idea itself seems the same as using dielectric fluids and the latter are clean, non-toxic and ozone-friendly."
Tom Halfhill, an expert with electronics industry publication Microprocessor Report, says the solution is far from ideal. "There are a number of exotic ways to cool electronics, all the way up to vats of liquid helium," he told New Scientist "However, a better solution is to avoid generating all that heat in the first place. Heat is wasted power. Heat is inefficiency. Reducing the power consumption of processors and other components is more desirable than exotic cooling."
*shrug*
This probably isn’t going to be of much use on desktops, but such an improvement in efficiency would be great for laptops and portable computing systems.
Though this new idea is intriguing...it sure will make hardware upgrades a lot messier....and the data center will now smell like French Fries. =;^)
Your thoughts?
Minus 20C? Doesn’t oil turn into lard at that temperature? That’s why vehicles in cold climates need block heaters to keep the oil liquid.
Synthetics can do just fine at -20°F. CPUs just love running with such low temps too. You can really push 'em.
It appears his application is for high-density data center use, i.e. servers.
Oil-bath cooling for a notebook would be... um... messy. :-/
significant shrinkage
amateurs.
CERN: Huge Refrigerators Create Temps Colder than Space
LiveScience | 10 April 2007 10:26 am ET | LiveScience Staff
Posted on 04/11/2007 3:46:33 PM EDT by Ernest_at_the_Beach
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-chat/1815707/posts
:’)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.