Replies

I think Kim has changed her "opinion" regarding the case but not her story. Initially she said it was a "crock", then in an AP interview she said she thought the guys were guilty. But she has never backed up what the accuser said in her police statement. She has never said they were forcibly separated and that she helped Precious get dressed. Apparently she says on 60 Minutes that this is the first she has ever heard of that. At first I thought that was impossible but now I'm starting to believe it. Her eyes really pop out when Bradley reads that to her.

As for Kim's original handwritten police statement, I think that's as close to the truth as you'll ever get with her. I do think she left a few things out though. Most notably, she left out the big argument she had with the players over money. This was heard by Bissey. She also made a big deal out of the fact that Crystal seemed to have lost her money and she went looking for her things. She may have looked but I think she was trying to throw suspicion off herself. I think it's likely that she stole Crystal's money.

Exactly. Kim Roberts might not win the "Most consistent witness" award, but for Precious's father to say she is not reliable because she changed her story-well,
I doubt Kim comes anywhere close to being as inconsistent as Precious (or her father, for that matter).

But she has never backed up what the accuser said in her police statement.

Kim made her written statement on March 22nd.. If I'm not mistaken the final version of the AV's statement wasn't documented until April 6th or so.

There's no telling what Kim might have agreed to write if the cops had a final draft from the AV prior to Kim's statement.

In Kim's written statement she say this:

We did sip the drinks but Precious’ cup fell into the sink.

But on the same day Hinman describes her as saying...

. THERE WAS A KNOCK ON THE DOOR AND WE WERE HANDED TWO DRINKS OF EQUAL AMOUNTS. SHE STATED SHE SIPPED THE DRINKS (RUM AND COKE SHE THINKS) BUT PRECIOUS CUP FELL INTO THE SINK DUMPING OUT THE CONTENTS, SHE THINKS THE VICTIM HAD A COUPLE DRINKS FROM HERS BUT SHE WAS NOT SURE.

And even later on May 11th she tells the NandO...

Roberts told Newsweek that players gave them mixed drinks. She did not drink hers; the other dancer drank half her glass, spilled it and then drank all of Roberts' drink. "She started stumbling," Roberts said. "When I think back on it, she had a glassy look in her eye."

She has progressively changed her stories based on whom she thought had the upper hand. Now that it's going against Nifong... So are her stories...