Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Terri Schiavo's Brother Says Ellen Goodman Op-Ed Misguided, Inaccurate
LifeNews.com ^ | September 25, 2006 | Steven Ertelt

Posted on 09/26/2006 2:31:27 PM PDT by rhema

St. Petersburg, FL -- Bobby Schindler, Terri Schiavo’s brother, says a recent nationally syndicated editorial written by columnist Ellen Goodman is misguided and inaccurate. The following is a copy of his letter to the editor to the Boston Globe newspaper reaction to her opinion piece, “Playing vegetative mind games.”

Ms. Goodman:

I read your recent column, "Playing vegetative mind games".

The lengths that you and many of your colleagues continue to go to in order to somehow justify the barbaric killing of my sister, Terri, are truly sad and in my opinion a tragic reflection of how you and those that think like you have truly misplaced your humanity.

What is so profoundly frightening about what you wrote is the effort to use this scientifically inaccurate persistent vegetative state (PVS) label to indiscriminately decide when it’s permissible to kill those that are disabled. As you pointed out in your column, there are tens of thousands of people that have experienced a brain injury. The idea that certain lives have somehow lost their meaning because they exist in this so-called PVS, which according to you, is some type of "horrifying" state of consciousnesses or lack thereof (not quite sure how you or anyone would have knowledge of this) is equally alarming. It is this form of lethal bigotry that my family battled in our efforts to get help for my sister.

Recently, a British research study concluded that the PVS diagnosis is in fact misdiagnosed more than 40% of the time. Recognizing this finding along with this most recent discovery, and others similar to it, one with any common sense would have to agree that using the completely subjective PVS “diagnosis” as the basis to kill the disabled is clearly outrageous.

Incidentally, I find it remarkable how the voice of disabled community has been all but ignored by most of the popular media. Why are the persons that are truly in harm’s way, the disabled, rarely mentioned? There were thirty (30) local and national disability organizations that publicly spoke out on behalf of Terri, yet their voices have been silenced.

It seems to me that in spite of your opinion (and many in the mainstream media for that matter) the general public is just not agreeing with what you and so many morally misguided individuals are promoting. Fortunately, good people know the fundamental difference between right and wrong, and have compassion for those that are most vulnerable. Regardless of these dehumanizing labels, they realize that preying on the brain injured is not a way of showing kindness, nor is it some form of altruism, but rather a selfish and cowardly act by those who justify in their minds that the killing of the weak and voiceless is somehow "okay".

It comes down to this Ms. Goodman, and it's really very simple - it's not up to you or anyone to decide.

Perhaps if you ever had the opportunity to care for someone like Terri you would understand why your article is so offensive not only to her memory and my family, but also to the tens of thousands of brain injured persons that you claim to speak for.

Bobby Schindler

Terri Schindler Schiavo Foundation

5562 Central Avenue, Suite 2

St. Petersburg, FL 33707

727-490-7603

www.terrisfight.org

P.S. I thought it would be helpful to you to include the names of the medical professionals, many being distinguished neurologists, who either believed that Terri was not in a PVS or could have been helped if Michael Schiavo and/or the courts would have permitted it (all of their affidavits submitted to Judge George Greer can be accessed on terrisfight.org).

Perhaps your next article might make mention of them.

1. Dr. Jay Carpenter

2. Dr. Fred Webber

3. Dr. Jacob Green

4. Dr. Alexander T. Gimon

5. Dr. William Scott Russell

6. Dr. Joseph L. Brunner

7. Dr. David L. Coulter

8. Dr. David Hopper

9. Dr. Beatrice Engstrand

10. Dr. Alyse Eytan

11. Dr. Harry Sawyer Goldsmith

12. Dr. William M. Hammesfahr

13. Dr. Paul Harch

14. Dr. Carolyn Heron

15. Dr. Lawrence Huntoon

16. Pamela Hyink, SLP

17. Dr. Jill Joyce

18. Dr. James P. Kelly

19. Dr. Philip R. Kennedy

20. Dr. Kyle Lakas

21. Dr. Peter J. Luca

22. Dr. William Maxfield

23. Dr. Peter J. Morin

24. Myra Stinson, CCC-SLP

25. Dr. James Avery

26. Dr. Ricardo Senno

27. Dr. Stanely A. Terman

28. Dr. J. Michael Uszler

29. Dr. Richard Weidman

30. Dr. Jon David Young

31. Dr. Thomas Mark Zabiega

32. Dr. Ralph Ankenman

33. Carla Sauer Iyer, RN

34. C. Johnson, CNA

35. Heidi Law, CNA

36. Sara Green Mele, MS, CCC-SLP

37. Dr. Laurie Barclay

38. Dr. Rodney Dunaway

39. Dr. George Isajiw

40. Dr. Leonard P. Rybak

41. Dr. Richard Neubauer


TOPICS: Local News
KEYWORDS: bobbyschindler; ellengoodman; euthanasia; prolife; terrischiavo
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-45 last
To: Darren Williams
However all of this is a moot point now that she is dead and an autopsy has been done. Physical examination of her brain confirmed that her cerebral cortex had liquified.

Not true. Such a diagnosis cannot be made on a corpse. And the ME stated as much.

Go troll somewhere else besides Schiavo and Irwin threads.

41 posted on 09/27/2006 9:27:55 AM PDT by DJ MacWoW (If you think you know what's coming next....You don't know Jack.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 40 | View Replies]

To: DJ MacWoW

could starvation cause the cerebral cortex to liquify? I am not an MD so i don'y know but I do know starvation is a proccess whereby the the fat and muscles are actually consumed by proteins and enzymes in oreder to provide nourishment to the body.
as far as Ellen Goodman goes i have nothing good to say but I will say it as succinctly as I can- she is the biggest liberal bitch to ever spew her liberal. pro baby murder, pro gay "marriage socialist BS outta Boston. She is enough of a liberal wacko to be ted kennedy's wife. She is deplorable, despicable and just plain sick in the head-and those are just her good points.


42 posted on 10/01/2006 12:09:07 AM PDT by riverdog
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 41 | View Replies]

To: riverdog

A brain needs to be living for an awareness test. The human brain is a complex organ that science knows very little about. There are threads on FR about the MEs report that you'll find if you do a search. There's all kinds of info.


43 posted on 10/01/2006 6:20:13 PM PDT by DJ MacWoW (If you think you know what's coming next....You don't know Jack.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 42 | View Replies]

To: rhema

What i dont understand is why the legislature cannot pass a law that requires a person to make a legal document stating that you want life support measures to cease after a certain measure of time or whatever. you have a right to refuse medical care.we have laws that make you go through formalities to transfer assets, ie. a will.

if you do not have such a legal document stating your wishes in a case like terri schiavo's, then the default position is life support until you die a natural death.

this will take the decision away from somebody else and put it in the hands of the person who's life is obviously affected.

A life support machine is not a life-giving machine it only supports the life that is already there, so life will not go on "indefinitely" like someone on this thread erroneously believed.


44 posted on 11/03/2006 11:34:51 AM PST by Vinny
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Comment #45 Removed by Moderator


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-45 last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson