Her father found her, but he was not alone at the time. A family friend was with him. Yes the scene was compromised. Yes, the police totally screwed up the handling of this case. But, I think you need a lot more solid proof before you lightly accuse a child(or anyone for that matter) of such a heinous crime.
There is absolutely NO evidence that her brother had anything to do with the murder.
Ping to post #76.
I'm not accusing the brother, personally, I think it was an ouside stalker, but my point is that the screw up, instead of eliminating him as a suspect, did the opposite, and allowed everyone to be tainted with (probably false) suspicion.
With a compromised scene, anyone who is there can't be reasonably eliminated, her father and his buddy finding her body had negative consequences.
Its a tragedy, I do think he is innocent, but he will never be free from speculation due to the inability of the police screw up and the fact that he was there.
I can't imagine going through life as an innocent man being accused of the most heinous crime simply because I was in the wrong place and someone else screwed up so badly, that its quite belivable that I am guilty.